Skip to content
The Argand

Anti-EnshittificationPledge


Never Betray the User

They took search — the thing that was supposed to connect humanity to its own knowledge — and turned it into a slot machine. They filled it with ads, stole from the people who make the web worth visiting, and then pasted a hallucinating AI on top and called it progress. Cory Doctorow named the disease. We're building the cure.

read the pledge

What We Will Never Do

I

We will never sell your data.

Your searches are yours. Not ours to auction. Not a revenue stream. Not a "personalization opportunity." We don't build behavioral profiles. We don't track you across the web. We don't sell your attention to the highest bidder. That entire business model is a betrayal, and we refuse to participate in it. Privacy isn't a premium feature we'll gate behind a subscription someday. It's a constraint we build around, from day one, permanently.

II

We will never steal traffic from creators.

When you search, you're looking for someone else's work. A journalist who spent weeks on a story. A blogger who actually knows what they're talking about. A small business that built something real. Our job is to connect you to them — not to scrape their content, summarize it into a box, and keep you on our page. Every result is a doorway, not a dead end. We don't do knowledge panels. We don't do AI overviews. We do links — the thing the web was built on.

III

We will never index AI-generated slop.

The web is drowning. Millions of pages generated by machines to game search rankings, written by nothing, for no one, about everything. Fake product reviews. Fake news sites. Fake recipe blogs. Fake mushroom foraging guides that could literally kill you. We actively detect and filter this garbage out of our index. You came here for human knowledge, human expertise, human voices. That's what you'll get.

IV

We will never let ads corrupt search.

Yes, we run ads. We're honest about that — it's how we keep the lights on. But our ads will never track you, and they will never come before search quality. This isn't a hypothetical risk. Google had the best search engine on earth and deliberately made it worse because degraded results meant more ad clicks meant more revenue. They chose money over you. We'd rather go broke than do that. Ads are clearly labeled, contextual only, and the search results you see are ranked by relevance — not by who paid the most.

V

We will never enshittify.

No bait-and-switch. No paywalling features that were free. No inserting "sponsored" results disguised as organic ones. No degrading the experience to juice quarterly earnings. The product gets better over time, or we've failed. That's not a slogan — it's the only acceptable outcome. The moment we start optimizing for our shareholders instead of our users is the moment we become the thing we set out to replace.

Enforcement

This isn't marketing copy. These commitments are structurally binding. If Argand is ever acquired, merged, or handed to new leadership, these pledges travel with it — they are non-negotiable conditions of the company's existence. Any future leader who violates this pledge is not "pivoting" or "evolving the business." They are destroying it. And we will build the legal and organizational framework to make sure that's exactly what happens. If Argand can't exist without enshittifying, then Argand should not exist. We would rather shut down, open-source everything, and walk away than become another name on the timeline below.

Why I Built This

I grew up with a search engine that just worked. You typed what you wanted, you found it. That's gone now — buried under ads, scraped into AI summaries, gamed by SEO farms. I built Argand alone because I got angry enough to stop complaining and start building.

I'm a socialist. I believe technology should serve people, not extract from them. Argand needs money to run — servers cost money, bandwidth costs money — and we'll make that money honestly, through ads that don't track you and services worth paying for. But I don't need all the money in the world. I need enough to keep the lights on and pay the people who help build this. That's it.

I'm not in this to get rich. I'm in this because search used to work and now it doesn't, and the people who broke it did it on purpose, for profit, knowing exactly what they were destroying. I want to kill and dethrone Google — not to become the next Google, but to prove that the new global standard should be "products that actually work correctly."

Nic Weyand
Founder, Argand
Signed March 2026
That was 133 days ago. The pledge holds.

This page will always live at argand.org/aep. If it ever disappears, we've broken our own pledge. This document may be amended to add new commitments, but never to weaken existing ones. All changes are tracked in our public git history.

How We Got Here

The Betrayal Timeline

This isn't ancient history. This is a documented record of promises broken, trust violated, and users exploited — by the companies that control the internet. Every entry is sourced. None of this is disputed.

This timeline is unfortunately not comprehensive — there are far too many betrayals to fit on one page. But it showcases the clear, undeniable pattern of abuse.

The Promises
1998 Microsoft
Bundled IE to kill Netscape
DOJ found Microsoft maintained its monopoly by bundling Internet Explorer with Windows. Internal emails: "cut off Netscape's air supply." Netscape: 80% → 0%.
2004 Google
"Don't be evil."
Google's S-1: "We believe strongly that in the long term, we will be better served by a company that does good things for the world."
The Erosion
2006 Facebook
News Feed launched without consent
Broadcast all user activity to friends without warning. 700,000 protested. Zuckerberg apologized. Kept the feature. The template: launch invasive, apologize, never revert.
2007 Facebook
Beacon broadcasts purchases to friends
Tracked purchases on partner sites, posted to News Feeds. A man's Christmas gift broadcast to his wife. Settlement: $9.5M. Cross-site tracking became their business model.
2010 Google
Buzz exposes Gmail contacts publicly
Made your most-emailed contacts public by default. Exposed abuse victims' contacts, journalists' sources. FTC consent decree. Zero fine.
2012 Facebook
"Pivot to Video" — inflated metrics destroy newsrooms
Inflated video metrics by 150–900%. "Video is the future." Newsrooms fired writers, hired video teams. Fraud revealed, newsrooms gutted. Settled $40M.
2012 Facebook
Emotional manipulation on 689,003 users
Without consent, showed users more negative content to see if it made them sadder. It did. Defense: Terms of Service.
2013 Google
Killed Google Reader to push Google+
Murdered the blogosphere's backbone to force users onto a failed social network. RSS as mainstream distribution died. Content funneled into algorithmic feeds.
The Extraction
2014 Google
Zero-click search takes over
Knowledge Panels, Snippets, answer boxes. Google scrapes other sites' content. By 2020: 64%+ searches end with zero clicks.
2015 Spotify
Per-stream payments collapse
~$0.007/stream → below $0.003. Then 1,000 streams/year minimum. $14B revenue. Median artist: under $1,000/year.
2016 Instagram
Killed the chronological feed
Engagement algorithm despite #RIPInstagram. Organic reach collapsed. Instagram became pay-to-play.
2016 Uber
Driver pay bait-and-switch
Paid drivers well to build the network, then systematically slashed rates once drivers were dependent. Leaked internal docs showed executives knew exactly what they were doing.
2016–18 YouTube
Adpocalypse: mass demonetization
Revenue 50–80% overnight. Opaque rules. LGBTQ+ creators disproportionately hit. Millions of small creators cut off.
2018 Facebook
Cambridge Analytica: 87 million profiles
Data harvested for political targeting. Facebook knew since 2015. FTC fine: $5B — 11 days of revenue.
2018 Google
Drops "Don't be evil"
Buried in a rewrite while building Pentagon drone AI. 4,000 protested. A dozen resigned. Contract completed.
2018 Tumblr
NSFW ban destroys communities
AI flagged Renaissance art and sand dunes. LGBTQ+, artists, fan fiction — gone. $1.1B → sold for ~$3M.
2019 Amazon
Used seller data to clone products
Marketplace data → Amazon Basics clones. Contradicted sworn testimony to Congress. Ad biz: $46.9B.
2020 Google
Lied about location tracking
Tracked you after you turned it off. Internal emails: deceptive by design. 40-state settlement: $391.5M.
2020 Apple
30% App Store tax — pay or don't exist
Epic sued. Trial revealed 78% profit margins on the App Store. Apple banned apps from even telling users cheaper options existed outside the store. Judge found anti-steering rules anticompetitive.
2020 Google
41% of first page is Google's own stuff
Organic results — the actual web — pushed below the fold.
2021 Facebook
Instagram harms teen girls. They knew.
Worsened body image for 1 in 3 teenage girls. Algorithm promoted rage for engagement. Response: rebrand as "Meta."
2021 Microsoft
Windows 11 obsoletes 240M working PCs
Arbitrary chip requirements. Buy new or pay $30/yr for patches. 240M functional PCs → e-waste.
The Collapse
Ongoing Google
293+ products killed. Users abandoned.
Google Reader, Inbox, Hangouts, Stadia, Domains, Podcasts — 293 products and counting. Each one taught users that depending on Google is a risk. Trust destroyed for "focus."
2022 Twitter / X
Musk destroys Twitter in real time
$44B. Fired 80%. Dissolved Trust & Safety. Sold verification. Boosted himself. Hate speech +202%. Ad revenue −59%.
2023 Reddit
API pricing kills apps, sells data to Google
$12K/50M requests to kill Apollo. CEO: mods are "landed gentry." IPO: $203M deal selling user content for AI.
2023 Netflix
Password-sharing crackdown
"Sharing is caring" → pay extra or get locked out. Netflix explicitly encouraged sharing for years to grow the platform, then pulled the rug once competitors appeared.
2023 Spotify
Ghost artists populate your playlists
Spotify filled curated playlists with pseudonymous "ghost artists" — cheap tracks from production houses with flat-fee deals. Real artists pushed out of discovery. Lower per-stream costs for Spotify.
Jan 2023
Doctorow names it: "enshittification"
Be good → abuse users → abuse everyone. 2023 Word of the Year. Not new — just finally named.
2024 Google
Search quality at documented low
Researchers proved it: SEO spam dominates. API leak: Google lied about ranking signals for years.
2024 Meta
Trains AI on all your posts. No opt-out.
Everything you ever posted → AI training. EU got cumbersome opt-out. Everyone else? No recourse.
May 2024 Google
AI Overviews: "put glue on pizza"
Hallucinating AI above all results. Glue pizza. Eat rocks. Joke Reddit comment as medical advice.
2024 OpenAI
Safety nonprofit → $157B for-profit
Built to ensure AI benefits humanity. Safety board ousted. Became the thing it was supposed to prevent.
2024 Everyone
AI slop drowns the web
1,000+ fake news sites. AI books: mushroom guides that could kill you. Dead internet theory became fact.
2024 Everyone
AI trains on the entire web without consent
NYT, Authors Guild, Getty sued. OpenAI trained on pirated books. Humanity's creative output appropriated.
Aug 2024 Google
Found guilty: illegal search monopoly
Paid Apple $26.3B/year to stay default. Quality declining. DOJ wants Chrome sold. Ad tech monopoly too.
Jan 2025 Meta
Ends fact-checking. Donates $1M to Trump.
Dropped fact-checking. Trust & Safety → Texas. 40,000 moderators' work: abandoned.
2025 Google / Meta
2,900+ newspapers dead. 200+ news deserts.
50% of digital ad spend. Zero journalism produced.

Twenty-eight years. Dozens of companies. Billions of users.

The same pattern every single time.

Be good → get big → extract everything → repeat.

We are building the exit.

Try the alternative.

Search that respects you, rewards creators, and refuses to rot.